Caleb Downs of Alabama and Malaki Starks playing in the same secondary—is that even possible? Kirby Smart, the coach at Georgia, can, and it just could work out for him. According to numerous published stories quoting sources, Downs, a freshman from Mill Creek High School who was named to the Crimson Tide’s first team All-American this past season, was allegedly “preparing to enter the transfer portal” on Wednesday. In the 2023 recruiting cycle, Downs’ final two destinations were the Bulldogs and Ohio State. By all accounts, Smart and the Bulldogs have remained cordial with Downs’ family in the interim. Following Alabama’s victory against Georgia in the SEC Championship game on December 2, Smart made it a point to sprint across the field to embrace Downs. In response to Downs, Smart said
“He doesn’t look like a freshman at all. He looks like a guy that’s been playing for three years,” Smart said. “He’s instinctive. He’s fast. He’s fearless. He’s everything that he was in high school. I’ve seen him play about a hundred 7-on-7 games at our stadium and at our facility when his high school team came over all the time. He’s everything that we thought he was – punt returner, just a football player that is instinctive, great tackler, just what you draw up when you want a defensive back.” Downs did it all for the Crimson Tide this past season. The 6-foot, 203-pound athlete led Alabama in tackles with 107, with two interceptions and four pass breakups. Downs was also a part-time punt returner for the Tide, returning four, including one for an 85-yard touchdown. With three seasons of eligibility remaining, Downs would be paired in a Georgia secondary that already features an All-American safety in Starks. Junior Javon Bullard, who played alongside Starks last season, declared for the NFL draft.
Helping the Bulldogs’ cause is the fact that they now employ one of Downs’ coaches from last season. Travaris Robinson, who was cornerbacks coach at Alabama last year, agreed Friday to join the Bulldogs as safeties coach and co-defensive coordinator. Robinson and Smart also embraced at the end of the SEC title game. Georgia already has accepted one of Downs’ teammates through the portal. Jake Pope, a redshirt freshman from Buford, also spurned the Bulldogs for the Crimson Tide out of high school. Of course, none of that assures that Downs will land in Athens. He is expected to command one of the more significant NIL deals in the history of the transfer portal. And not only are Georgia, Ohio State and virtually every other power-conference school expected to make overtures for Downs’ services, but he could choose to remain in Tuscaloosa, where Alabama is desperate to right its suddenly listing ship.
Downs’ testing the market is the result of Nick Saban deciding last week to retire after 17 years as Alabama’s head coach. The Crimson Tide has since hired former Washington coach Kalen DeBoer. But current NCAA rules provide a 30-day window for members of a college team to explore the transfer portal in the wake of a coaching change.
